I was under the assumption, that when we were all together or two met, if the challenge coin came out and you didn't have yours, you buy the beer. I was not aware that this could apply to online challenges. Hell, one of mine is around my neck and the other two are put up for a while till Hotlanta. But, leave it to Bob to come up with a different twist. Since this was between Bob and I on line and no one else was involved, then he gets the free round. He made the challenge to me and I concede to the fact he caught me flat footed.